Two Thomistic Talks on the Problem of Evil

I had the privilege of listening to two Thomistic lectures on the problem of evil from two sharp, female philosophers.

Lecture #1 – Dr. Gloria Frost

First, Dr. Gloria Frost delivered a lecture entitled The Goodness of God and the Evil in Our World: Aquinas on the Problem of Evil.

Pay extra attention to Dr. Frost’s discussion of Aquinas’ commentary on the book of Job. She explains some tough truths that are spot on. Frost teaches with clarity throughout the talk and offers a lot of important thoughts on evil and suffering.

One critical remark. I think she steps away from Thomistic principles somewhat in the Q and A. In offering what sounds like a free-will defense, Dr. Frost sounds more like a contemporary apologist than a Thomist. She does not use the phrase free-will defense, and she probably does not endorse it as a theodicy, but the listeners most likely construed her remark as approval of such a line of reasoning.

Lecture #2 – Dr. Jennifer Frey

 Second, Dr. Jennifer Frey delivered a lecture entitled Aquinas on Sin, Suffering, and Evil. 

Take notes on Dr. Frey’s detailed discussion and analysis of what Aquinas takes sin and evil to be. She explores the difference between failing in a skill and failing in moral action. Frey draws important distinctions that help one navigate the issues surrounding evil.

Also, in the Q and A, a listener asks about Fr. Davies work on the subject (which I’ve discussed here). Dr. Frey offers helpful remarks in support of Fr. Davies work. She also stresses the correct pronunciation of his name! It’s pronounced “Day-Vis.”

Concluding Thoughts

For more great talks from a Thomistic perspective, check out the Thomistic Institute. For more on a Thomistic approach to the Problem of Evil, check out this series of posts.